Main design consideration in boards development

Design Consideration in Boards Development – Concept Overview

The design of printed circuit boards (PCBs) is a pivotal phase in electronic product development. It serves as the physical foundation upon which the entire electronic system operates. While trial and error can be part of the prototyping journey, focusing on key design considerations early can drastically save time, resources, and costs. This article explores the main design factors engineers must consider when developing PCB prototypes, balancing electrical performance, manufacturability, thermal management, and mechanical constraints.

Example of an electronic board design layout showing component placement and routing
Figure 1: Example of electronic board design emphasizing component placement and routing strategies.

Thought Process

PCB design is a multi-disciplinary challenge that requires a holistic approach. The process begins with defining clear requirements, including electrical specifications, mechanical constraints, thermal limits, and cost targets. The goal is to create a layout that not only functions electrically but is also manufacturable and testable. Early decisions on material choice, layer stackup, and component placement have far-reaching impacts on signal integrity, thermal performance, and assembly complexity.

Electrical and Signal Integrity Considerations

Signal integrity is critical, especially for high-speed or sensitive analog circuits. Controlled impedance routing, proper grounding, and minimizing crosstalk through strategic trace spacing are essential. Designers must treat traces as transmission lines when signal rise times are fast relative to trace lengths. Impedance matching and careful via placement help prevent signal reflections and maintain data integrity.

Thermal Management

Heat dissipation is a common failure cause in PCBs. Designers should identify hotspots early and use thermal vias, copper pours, and appropriate substrate materials to spread and dissipate heat. Component placement can also aid thermal management by positioning heat-generating parts near board edges or areas with better airflow. Simulation tools and thermal measurements during prototyping help validate thermal strategies.

Thermal management on a PCB showing heat dissipation techniques
Figure 2: Thermal management techniques on a PCB, including thermal vias and copper pours.

Mechanical, Size, and Component Placement

Mechanical constraints such as board size, mounting holes, and enclosure fit dictate the PCB outline and component placement. Efficient floorplanning groups related functional blocks, minimizing trace lengths and improving signal integrity. Connectors are placed on edges for accessibility, while sensitive components are positioned to minimize noise coupling and facilitate heat dissipation. Consistent orientation and verified footprints reduce assembly errors.

Manufacturing Constraints

Design for Manufacturability (DFM) principles ensure the PCB can be produced reliably and cost-effectively. Trace widths and spacing must align with fabricator capabilities. Layer stackup should be optimized to avoid warping and support impedance control. Material selection balances performance and cost, with FR-4 being common for general applications and specialized laminates used for high-frequency or thermal demands. Solder mask and silkscreen clearances prevent defects during assembly.

Material and Cost Considerations

Material choice influences electrical performance, thermal management, and cost. Standard FR-4 substrates offer a good balance for many applications, but high-frequency or high-temperature designs may require advanced materials like Rogers or metal-core substrates. Cost optimization involves minimizing layer count, relaxing trace tolerances where possible, and selecting readily available components to avoid supply chain issues.

Debugging Stage and End-of-Line Tests

Prototyping includes rigorous testing phases: visual inspection, electrical rule checks, functional testing, and environmental stress testing. Test points should be accessible for debugging. Automated optical inspection (AOI), in-circuit testing (ICT), and thermal imaging help identify defects early. Iterative prototyping cycles address discovered issues, applying rework strategies like bodge wires or component replacement before finalizing the design for production.

Potential Applications

These design considerations apply broadly across electronic product development, from consumer devices to industrial controls, medical equipment, and aerospace systems. Each application imposes unique requirements on reliability, environmental resilience, and regulatory compliance, but the fundamental principles of PCB design and prototyping remain consistent. At TrigoPi, we enjoy pushing these boundaries, developing prototypes that meet stringent performance criteria while optimizing for manufacturability and cost.

Challenges & Next Steps

One of the biggest challenges in PCB prototyping is balancing competing design goals—maximizing electrical performance while minimizing cost and ensuring manufacturability. As technology advances, boards become denser and operate at higher frequencies, increasing the complexity of signal integrity and thermal challenges. Continuous learning and leveraging advanced simulation tools, coupled with close collaboration between design and manufacturing teams, are essential. At TrigoPi, our engineers thrive on these challenges, constantly refining our processes to deliver robust prototypes faster and more efficiently.

Practical Considerations

  • Plan component placement carefully to optimize routing and thermal dissipation.
  • Use verified component footprints and maintain consistent orientation.
  • Design layer stackup to support impedance control and reduce board warping.
  • Apply DFM guidelines early to avoid costly redesigns and manufacturing delays.
  • Incorporate adequate test points and design for testability to ease debugging.
  • Validate thermal performance with simulation and prototype measurements.
  • Iterate prototypes systematically, documenting changes and lessons learned.

By focusing on these key areas during PCB development and prototyping, engineers can reduce trial-and-error cycles, accelerate time-to-market, and improve product reliability. It’s the kind of challenge that keeps our engineers awake at night—in a good way.

References

  • https://www.mclpcb.com/blog/pcb-layout-considerations/
  • https://www.allpcb.com/blog/pcb-assembly/the-ultimate-guide-to-pcb-prototyping-assembly-from-design-to-functional-prototype.html
  • https://www.analog.com/en/resources/analog-dialogue/articles/what-are-the-basic-guidelines-for-layout-design-of-mixed-signal-pcbs.html
  • https://www.protoexpress.com/blog/building-pcb-prototype-from-scratch-designers-guide/
  • https://blog.epectec.com/design-for-manufacturability-key-considerations-in-pcb-prototyping
  • https://www.protoexpress.com/blog/building-pcb-prototype-from-scratch-designers-guide/
  • https://www.mclpcb.com/blog/ipc-standards-for-pcbs/
  • https://www.pnconline.com/blog/pcb-prototyping-best-practices-for-fast-and-accurate-results/
  • https://resources.pcb.cadence.com/blog/2020-pcb-prototyping-and-fabrication
  • https://resources.altium.com/p/emi-and-signal-integrity-multi-board-pcb-designs
  • https://www.protoexpress.com/blog/12-pcb-thermal-management-techniques-to-reduce-pcb-heating/
  • https://www.advancedpcb.com/en-us/resources/blog/best-practices-for-creating-perfectly-designed-printed-circuit-boards/
Download PDF file